The following is an opinion editorial provided by Ike Isaacson, SVP Government & Regulatory Relations, VGM Group:
This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260820941759/en/
Mike “Ike” Isaacson, SVP Government & Regulatory Relations, VGM Group
Across the country, more states and health plans are turning to third-party administrators (TPAs) to manage durable medical equipment and other healthcare services. While these arrangements are often promoted as cost-containment solutions, they represent a short-sighted response to a much deeper challenge facing our healthcare system.
The promise is simple: reduce costs through centralized contracting and network management. The reality, however, is far more troubling. What may appear to be a financial win on paper risks creating a cascade of unintended consequences that will ultimately harm patients, providers, manufacturers, and the healthcare system as a whole.
The first casualties are often the local providers that have spent decades serving their communities. Across the country, suppliers are finding their contracts canceled or they are seeing their reimbursement reduced to rates that don’t cover their cost of goods, despite years—sometimes generations—of caring for patients in their hometowns. These are the providers who know their patients by name, respond after hours, deliver equipment in emergencies, and make it possible for individuals with complex medical conditions to remain safely at home.
When local providers disappear, patient choice disappears with them.
The loss does not happen overnight. Initially, larger regional and national providers may step in to fill the void left behind by smaller suppliers. Policy makers and payers may point to this transition as evidence that access is being maintained. But that assessment overlooks a critical question: How long can providers sustain service at the reimbursement rates many TPAs are proposing?
Healthcare delivery is not immune to economic reality. Even large suppliers with greater purchasing power face limits. Lower reimbursement rates eventually compress margins to the point where maintaining service, product quality, staffing levels, inventory, and patient support becomes increasingly difficult. What begins as a strategy to reduce spending can quickly become a strategy that reduces access.
At the same time, the pressure extends beyond providers and reaches manufacturers.
Many manufacturers have traditionally relied on a broad network of suppliers, both large and small. As smaller providers are pushed out of the marketplace, manufacturers lose a significant segment of their customer base. While larger suppliers may purchase greater volume, they also demand lower prices. Over time, manufacturers face shrinking margins and difficult choices: raise prices, consolidate operations, move production overseas, or alter product offerings.
None of those outcomes strengthen healthcare delivery.
In fact, the continued consolidation encouraged by TPA-driven models creates a dangerous cycle. Fewer providers lead to fewer purchasing options. Fewer purchasing options lead to greater market concentration. Greater market concentration reduces competition, limits innovation, and ultimately weakens the resilience of the healthcare supply chain.
And who pays the price?
Patients.
Patients lose the ability to choose the provider that best meets their needs. They lose access to local expertise and personalized service. They face longer wait times, fewer service options, and growing barriers to care. Rural communities are often affected first, but the impact rarely stops there. What begins in rural America eventually spreads into suburban and urban markets, creating healthcare deserts that become increasingly difficult to reverse.
For the tens of millions of Americans who rely on home medical equipment to maintain their health, independence, and quality of life, these consequences are not merely inconvenient: They can be life-altering. Delays in receiving equipment, reduced education and support, diminished follow-up care, and limited access to trained professionals all contribute to poorer health outcomes and increased healthcare utilization. Patients who could have remained safely at home may instead find themselves in emergency rooms, hospitals, or long-term care settings.
That is not healthcare reform. It is cost shifting.
The fundamental flaw in the growing reliance on TPAs is the assumption that healthcare can be managed primarily through contracting and rate reductions. True healthcare value is not created by simply paying less for services. It is created by improving outcomes, preserving access, supporting innovation, and ensuring patients receive the right care at the right time and in the right setting.
The home care industry has long demonstrated its ability to do exactly that. Local providers, regional suppliers, national organizations, and manufacturers all play an essential role in a complex ecosystem that helps millions of Americans live independently and receive care in their homes. Undermining one part of that ecosystem ultimately weakens the entire system.
States and payers certainly face legitimate financial pressures. But solving those challenges requires thoughtful, long-term strategies—not blunt instruments that prioritize immediate savings over sustainable access.
Before expanding TPA models further, policymakers should ask a simple question: What does success look like five or ten years from now?
If the answer includes fewer providers, fewer choices, fewer manufacturers, and fewer patients receiving care in their communities, then we should not be surprised when today’s cost-saving solution becomes tomorrow’s healthcare crisis.
The healthcare system needs reforms that strengthen access, competition, and patient-centered care. TPAs may promise efficiency, but without careful consideration of their long-term impacts, they risk creating a lose-lose-lose scenario for providers, manufacturers, and—most importantly—the patients who depend on them.
View source version on businesswire.com: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260820941759/en/
Media gallery
